Use this chart to find waterways that are Class I or Class SD, which include most waterways around New York City, including the Hudson River, East River, Harlem River and others. Learn more about the NYS proposal to update water quality standards for these and other saline waterways, and how Riverkeeper is seeking to strengthen them, in this blog post. This chart can help you make specific comments about the waterways that matter most to you. Use our action alert template and personalize it with this information to help make a comment by June 20.
The state is proposing water quality criteria related to recreational uses of the water. Recreational water quality is assessed by measuring the concentration of the fecal indicator bacteria Enterococci (Entero) in the waterway. The presence of Entero in the water indicates the likelihood that pathogens associated with untreated sewage are also present. Two different measures are identified here in the rightmost columns, a Geometric Mean (GM), which can be thought of as way to measure average levels of contamination, and a Statistical Threshold Value (STV), which can be thought of as a way to measure the frequency of occasional high-contamination events. Learn more about these ways of measuring water quality in our How’s the Water report (see page 13).
For a list of all waters affected by the state’s rulemaking, see this list of all of NYS’s saline waters, including:
Waterbody Segment Name DEC ID Class | Segment Description | Suggested message to DEC | Proposed criteria would be designed to protect | Entero criteria (GM) that DEC previously deemed attainable | Proposed Entero criteria (GM / STV) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alley Creek 935-13, -17 Class I | From mouth at East River to sewer terminus in Queens. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one slightly less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 70 | 72 / 266 |
Arthur Kill 890-12 Class I | That portion within New York State from mouth (at an east?west line drawn from southernmost point of Staten Island at Ward Point to southernmost point of Perth Amboy, New Jersey, at Ferry Point) to Outerbridge Crossing. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Arthur Kill 890-13 Class SD | That portion within New York State from Outerbridge Crossing to Newark Bay outlet. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
Bedell Avenue Creek 899-27 Class I | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Benedic Creek 890-33 Class SD | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | There is no proposed change to the criteria for this waterway. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | ||
Bergen Basin 891-12 Class I | Tributary of Jamaica Bay in Queens. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 150 | 72 / 266 |
Bodine Creek 890-45 Class SD | Tidal portions in Staten Island | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, and do not support the goal of swimming in general. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Bridge Creek 890-44 Class SD | Near Port Ivory, Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
Bronx River 935-18 Class I | Tidal portion from mouth to East Tremont Avenue bridge in the Bronx. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Coney Island Creek 890-5 Class I | The creek in southern Brooklyn that is tributary to Gravesend Bay. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 315 | 72 / 266 |
East River 935-2 Class I | The East River from Rikers Island to the Whitestone Bridge, including waterfront areas of Queens and the Bronx, and including Flushing Bay in Queens. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
East River 890-52, 890-53 Class I | The East River from its mouth at New York Harbor past Randalls Island, including the river's Manhattan and Brooklyn waterfronts, and a portion of its Queens and Bronx waterfronts. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming, which is a currently documented use of this segment. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
East River 935-1 Class I | The East River between the eastern edge of Randalls Island and the eastern edge of Rikers Island, including waterfront areas of Queens and the Bronx. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Erie Basin 890-6.1 Class SD | The portion of New York Bay in Red Hook, Brooklyn, separated by peninsulas from Red Hook Channel and Gowanus Bay. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Flushing Creek 935-6 Class I | Mouth to Tide Gate Bridge in Flushing Meadow Park. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Fresh Kills 890-34 Class SD | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
Gowanus Canal 890-7 Class SD | Tributary of Gowanus Bay. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Great Kills Creek 890-19 Class I | Enters Great Kills Harbor at Great Kills Park in Staten Island | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Harlem River 890-56.1 Class I | Harlem River from Washington Bridge to junction with Hudson River at Spuyten Duyvil, including portions of Manhattan and the Bronx waterfronts. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming, which is a currently documented use of this segment. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Harlem River, Little Hell Gate, Bronx Kill 890-56 Class I | Harlem River from junction with Lower East River at southern tip of Randalls and Wards Islands, to Washington Bridge. Segment includes Little Hell Gate and the Bronx Kill. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming, which is a currently documented use of this segment. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Hawtree Basin 891-13 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary in Queens. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Hook Creek 891-3 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary in Queens. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Hook Creek tributaries 891-4, 891-7 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributaries in Queens. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Hudson River 864-1 Class I | The Hudson River along the Manhattan shoreline. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming, which is a currently documented use of this segment. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Kill Van Kull 890-15 Class SD | The Kill Van Kull along Staten Island from Newark Bay to the Kill Van Kull. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
New Creek 890-18 Class I | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Newark Bay 890-14 Class I | Southern portion of Bay lying north of Staten Island within New York State between outlet to Arthur Kill and outlet to Kill Van Kull. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not suppor the current uses of this waterway for paddling. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Newtown Creek or English Kills (Lower) 890-54 Class SD | Lower portion of Newtown Creek. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Newtown Creek or English Kills (Upper) 890-54 Class SD | Upper portion of Newtown Creek. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, do not support the goal of swimming in general, and do not support the current uses of this waterway for paddling. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
Oakwood Creek 899-20 Class I | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Old Mill Creek 891-16 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Old Place Creek 890-43 Class SD | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | There is no proposed change to the criteria for this waterway. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | ||
Raritan Bay portion 890-11 Class I | That sector of Bay within New York State off mouth of Arthur Kill bounded on south by line from southernmost point of Staten Island at Ward Point to New York?New Jersey boundary line at Great Beds Lighthouse; and bounded on north by line at mouth of Arthur Kill from southernmost point of Staten Island at Ward Point to southernmost point of Perth Amboy, New Jersey, at Ferry Point. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Sheepshead Bay 891-21 Class I | Portion of Jamaica Bay in Brooklyn. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Shellbank Basin 891-14 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary in Brooklyn. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Sleight Creek 890-31 Class SD | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | There is no proposed change to the criteria for this waterway. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | ||
Steinway Creek 935-4 Class SD | Tributary of the East River in Queens, also known as Luyster Creek. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, and do not support the goal of swimming in general. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Thurston Basin 891-8 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary in Queens. | While the proposed criteria for this segment are more protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, the proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 115 | 72 / 266 |
Trib. of East River 935-5 Class SD | Tidal tributary in Queens that connects to Bowery Bay, on the East River. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, and do not support the goal of swimming in general. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Jamaica Bay Tributaries 891-15 Class I | Jamaica Bay tributary | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Kill Van Kull tributaries 890-49, 890-50 Class SD | Tidal portions in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, and do not support the goal of swimming in general. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 35 | |
Arthur Kill Tributaries 890-30, 890-41, 890-42 Class SD | Including Tappan's Creek (trib. 7a), Neck Creek (trib. 9) and Sawmill Creek (trib. 9a) in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are less protective than criteria DEC previously deemed attainable, and do not support the goal of swimming in general. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | 115 | |
East River tributaries 935-11 Class I | Enter at Powell Cove, on the East River in Queens. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Jamaica Bay tributaries 891-17 Class I | Hendrix Creek (trib. 249a), Fresh Creek (trib. 250) and Paerdegat Basin (trib. 250a) in Brooklyn. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Jamaica Bay tributaries 891-2 Class I | Barbadoes Basin (trib. 237b), Verman Basin (trib. 237c), Sommerville Basin (trib. 237d) and Motts Basin (trib. 238a) in Queens. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |
Seatuck Creek tributaries 920-55 Class SD | Enter from east approximately 0.35 mile above mouth of Seatuck Creek in Suffolk County. | There is no proposed change to the criteria for this waterway. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | ||
Terrell River tributaries 920-35.1 Class SD | From Bay Avenue to source in Suffolk County. | There is no proposed change to the criteria for this waterway. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Fish survival, not paddling or swimming | ||
Westchester Creek and Pugsley Creek 935-47 Class I | Tidal portion of East River tributaries in the Bronx. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one slightly less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. The CSO Long Term Control Plan affecting this segment should be revisisted so that clean water investments have more impact sooner. | Paddling, not swimming | 70 | 72 / 266 |
Mill Creek 890-28 Class I | Tidal portion in Staten Island. | The proposed criteria for this segment are mixed, with one more and one less protective than DEC previously deemed attainable. The proposed criteria do not support the goal of swimming. | Paddling, not swimming | 35 | 72 / 266 |